A Slice of Heaven Wisconsin logo

Dessert Menu

Cheesecakes

$45 Cheesecakes

Choose from: Black Forest, Triple Chocolate, Chocolate Chip, Key Lime, Cappuccino with chocolate-covered almonds or chocolate-covered espresso beans, Marbled New York Style, Chocolate Raspberry, Lemon, Oreo®, Pumpkin with Caramel Swirl, Turtle, Amaretto, New York Cheesecake with choice of topping, Toffee Crunch Caramel, Mint Chocolate Chip or Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

$50-$60 Cheesecakes (fruit market price)

Choose from: Raspberry Swirl topped with raspberries, Ultimate Cheesecake topped with three types of fruit, New York Red/White/Blue topped with raspberries & blueberries & white chocolate curls & white chocolate drizzle, Chocolate Guinness®, Chocolate with choice of topping, New York with brownie bottom with choice of topping, Peanut Butter Swirl with Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups® or Taste of Home® Vanilla with lady fingers & fruit

Please see our gluten-free menu for other choices.

 

Cheesecake Cupcakes

Standard // $3.25 each // Minimum 12 per flavor

Mini // $1.50 each // Minimum 24 per flavor

Choose from flavors above

 

Gourmet Cheesecake Squares

Standard // $68.50-$90 // 35 pieces per order/flavor

Mini Bites  // $1.50 each //  Minimum 60 per flavor

Choose from flavors above

 

Pies

Apple Crumb // $22

Derby (chocolate chips, pecans & bourbon) // $22

Key Lime //  $20

Pumpkin // $12

Tollhouse® (chocolate chips with walnuts) // $17

Two-Crust Apple // $18

Two-Crust Sugar Free Apple // $18

Cranberry Nut // $22

Crunchy Caramel Apple // $28

Walnut // $18

Peanut Butter Cup // $25

Pecan // $18

German Sweet Chocolate in cookie dough pie crust // $22

Peanut Butter Silk // $25

Door County Cherry (in season) // $28

Cream Pie // $16

Choose from: chocolate, coconut or banana 

 

Specialty Desserts

Serves 16-20

Tiramisu // $65

Chocolate Éclair Dessert in oval shape // $45

Caramel Apple Dessert // $40

Tres Leches Cake // $65

 

Cakes

Serves 14-18

Fudge Ribbon Bundt // $25

Angel Food with 7-minute frosting // $30

Sour Cream Chocolate Pound // $25

Angel Food with chocolate filling & almonds // $40

Rum Cake // $45

 

9″ Two-Layered Cakes

16-18 pieces when cut into slab pieces or 14-16 pieces when cut into pie slices

Red Velvet with cream cheese icing // $40

Spice with cream cheese icing // $40

Chocolate Praline // $40

German Chocolate with coconut pecan icing // $45

Red Velvet with raspberry filling & fudge or cream cheese icing  // $45

Red Velvet with coconut/pecan filling & fudge icing // $45

Chocolate Fudge // $40 Chocolate Cake Marshfield Wisconsin

Carrot // $45

White Wedding Cake with white icing // $40

White Wedding Cake with filling & white icing // $45

Gooey Caramel Pecan // $45

Chocolate with peanut butter icing // $40

Lemon with lemon buttercream frosting // $40

Lemon with lemon buttercream frosting & filling // $45

Lemon Poppyseed with lemon buttercream frosting // $45

Lemon Poppyseed with lemon buttercream frosting & filling // $50

Lactose Free Chocolate Cake // $45

 

Sheet Cakes

Please call or email for a quote.

Speciality sheet cakes for all occasions – Weddings, Birthdays, Anniversaries, Showers, Religious Celebrations, etc.

Custom decorating also available.

For wedding consultations and taste testing, please call or email to set up an appointment.

 

Specialty Squares

Serves 12-15 // $35-$45

Choose from: Cherry Cobbler, Very Best Blueberry Cobbler, Chunky Apple Cake with butterscotch sauce, Italian Love Cake, Pumpkin Crunch Dessert with whipped cream topping, Chocolate Zucchini Cake or Melissa’s Decadent Fudge Lovers Cream Cheese Cake

 

Bars

Serves 15-20

Lemon // $15

Chocolate Chip Blonde Brownies // $20

Almond Joy® // $40

Cranberry // $30

Frosted Pumpkin // $30

Pumpkin Pie // $20

Nanaimo // $28 “Canada’s Favorite Confection”

Pecan Pie // $35

Almond // $30

Caramel Apple Cheesecake // $45

Nutty // $25

Chocolate Chip Toffee // $40

Carmelitas // $33

Fudge-Frosted Chocolate Brownies // $30

Kit Kat® // $24

Frito® // $17

Peanut Butter Fudge Brownies // $30

Mint Chocolate Fudge Brownies // $25

Key Lime // $18

7-Layer // $30

Cheesecake with crumb topping // $30

Oatmeal Cream Cheese Butterscotch // $38

Cheesy Nut // $28

Chocolate Crumb Bars // $33

Shortbread // $22

Red Velvet Brownies // $25

Double Delicious Cookie Bars with Chocolate Drizzle // $30

Pie Bars (apple, cherry or blueberry) // Serves 35 // $87

See our gluten-free menu for other choices

 

Cookies

$10-$12 per dozen // Minimum two dozen per flavor

Choose from: Chocolate Chip, Cowboy (family favorite with chocolate chips, oatmeal & nuts), Monster, Peanut Butter, Norwegian, Gingersnap, World’s Finest Sugar, Chewy Chocolate, Chocolate Chunk with Mixed Nut, Oatmeal Crunch, Pecan Supremes, Pecan Wedding Cakes, Black & Whites, Chocolate Crispy, Fudge with White Chocolate, Nutty White Chunk Chocolate-Glazed Shortbread, Farm (coconut, cornflakes & walnuts) or Three Chip

 

$12 per dozen //  Minimum two dozen per flavor

Choose from: Ginger with White Icing or Italian with White Icing

 

Cut-Out Cookies //  Minimum two dozen per flavor

Cut-outs with icing // $2 each

Cut-outs with icing in cello bag/curling ribbon // $4 each

 

Cupcakes

Full Size // $2.25-$3.25 each // Minimum 12 per flavor Cupcake baker in Marshfield, Wisconsin

Mini Size // $1 // Minimum 24 per flavor

Mini Size with filling // $1.50 // Minimum 24 per flavor

Choose from: White Wedding Cake with Buttercream Frosting, Lemon with Lemon Buttercream Frosting, Yellow with Buttercream Frosting, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, Chocolate with Fudge Frosting, Death by Oreo®, Chocolate with Peanut Butter Frosting & mini Reese’s® Peanut Butter Cup, Chocolate with Pecan Coconut Frosting, Red Velvet with Cream Cheese or Fudge Frosting, Pumpkin with Cream Cheese Frosting, Cinnamon Toast Crunch®, Chocolate with Cream Cheese Chocolate Chip Filling & Cream Cheese or Fudge Frosting, Chocolate Zucchini with Chocolate & Walnut Topping, Carrot with Cream Cheese Frosting or Oatmeal with Coconut & Pecan Frosting

 

Finishing Touches

Table linens, dessert stands & displays are available for rent for an additional fee.

This menu is not inclusive; please contact us to discuss special requests.

Prices subject to change.